【NEWS】2022年イグノーベル賞受賞「なぜ法律文書は不必要に難解なのかの分析」

専門知識ではなく、下手くそな文章が、法律文書の解読を困難にさせる

Poor writing, not specialized concepts, drives processing difficulty in legal language(July 2022)

Abstract
Despite their ever-increasing presence in everyday life, contracts remain notoriously inaccessible to laypeople. Why? Here, a corpus analysis (n ≈10 million words) revealed that contracts contain startlingly high proportions of certain difficult-to-process features–including low-frequency jargon, center-embedded clauses (leading to long-distance syntactic dependencies), passive voice structures, and non-standard capitalization–relative to nine other baseline genres of written and spoken English. Two experiments (N=184) further revealed that excerpts containing these features were recalled and comprehended at lower rates than excerpts without these features, even for experienced readers, and that center-embedded clauses inhibited recall more-so than other features. These findings (a) undermine the specialized concepts account of legal theory, according to which law is a system built upon expert knowledge of technical concepts; (b) suggest such processing difficulties result largely from working-memory limitations imposed by long-distance syntactic dependencies (i.e., poor writing) as opposed to a mere lack of specialized legal knowledge; and (c) suggest editing out problematic features of legal texts would be tractable and beneficial for society at-large.

(続きは↓)

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0010027722000580?via%3Dihub

面白くて考えさせられる研究に贈られるイグノーベル賞2022年度受賞者まとめ

「アメリカの科学誌「Improbable Research(風変わりな研究の年報)」が毎年主催している「笑い、そして考えさせられる研究」に対して贈られるイグノーベル賞の2022年度授賞式が、2022年9月16日7時に開催されました。第32回目となる今回は10部門の賞が用意され、日本人の研究者も受賞しました。(Gigazine)」

https://gigazine.net/news/20220916-ig-nobel-prize-2022/

これは、日本の法律でも一緒なのかを分析して欲しいですね。

コメントを残す

メールアドレスが公開されることはありません。

日本語が含まれない投稿は無視されますのでご注意ください。(スパム対策)